At the risk of appearing like an out of season Grinch, I’m going to be saying NO a lot more this year and I’m already uncomfortable with that because it’s a word I’m totally rubbish at using. But over the past years, I’ve said YES too much because it felt easier (at the time) than saying NO. I’ve bust my gut, I’ve not seen friends I wanted to meet up with because I’ve had no space in the diary, I’ve been panicking when things have cropped up with my parents’ ill health that I’ll be away on one of the many committed dates when they needed me, so this year my hand has been forced and I’m going on an intensive NO course. I’m going to grow a backbone, put my big girl pants on, remember that my elastic can only stretch so far.
Also, while we are on the 'wo-manning up' to things, let's throw in the c-word. CASH (almost as dirty as the other c-word). There’s something about cash in this business that makes it so hard to talk about. Other professionals work for money, electricians aren’t hobbyists hoping that someone will fling them some filthy lucre for a job occasionally, they trade their expertise for a wage. So why do writers find money so vulgar, so scary to talk about? Somehow I end up giving so much away for free because it feels icky to broker the subject of cold hard cash. I’m even cringing writing this. Goodness, what will anyone think of me talking about money *vision of a grasping Scrooge looms in my head*. But I’m going to because I think it’s important.
Firstly saying NO, is preferable to me saying YES and then ending up with a big fat MUG painted on my head. While sitting recovering from a seasonal bug recently, I contemplated just how much time I’d wasted because I couldn’t say NO. The amount of occasions when I’ve been cajoled into meeting up with a stranger who ‘wanted to run something past me’. I have no idea what I expected, but I should have said, ‘Run it past me on the telephone’ and ignored their insistence that they needed to do it face to face ‘but it won’t take long’ (it invariably does). So I’ve gone out for coffees or meetings with someone I don't know from Adam and ended up wasting all morning waiting for the big reveal. It’s nearly always a favour, or a crash course in ‘how to write a book’ and I’ve sat there thinking, ‘Why am I here when I haven’t seen my best mate for three months because I've told her I've got no time?’ On one occasion I sat there for two hours listening to a woman telling me how many times she’d seen David Tennant in person because she’d travelled anywhere he might show up, and how much she was in love with him before we got to the nitty-gritty: her daughter at primary school had written a book and she needed help in getting in published. Possibly the longest two hours of my life even though there are many contenders for that title. And though it might be very flattering that someone’s six year old child wants to interview me for their YouTube channel (1 post, 4 views) … need I go on? There's being polite, nice, wanting to encourage... and then there's just doing things because it feels wrong to say NO.
And when it’s a local person asking somehow that NO word makes it even worse to say because they might think you’re obliged to help coming from the same town and then they’ll tell everyone you are a stuck up arse if you say NO. I do believe that many people who ask a favour think they are the only one who does, not one of twenty that week. And you’d be amazed how many of those requests never feature the word ‘please’. Can I turn up at X's birthday party if I'm not doing anything on Friday and do a speech? Can I send X a signed book because her washing machine has blown up and she's a bit down? Can I mentor someone? You're local, can you advertise my husband's window cleaning business? As a fellow local writer can you read my book and tell me what you think? Can I... can I... can I? So many requests, enough to fill a diary. Please don't be offended by the word NO. I barely have enough time to shave both legs in one sitting doing my day job never mind all the extras.
As much as I love doing events, I have to be selective. It’s no good doing a seven hour round trip to talk to six people, however lovely they might be, especially when I'm struggling to finish a book or it's main launch period and I need as many sales as I can get so a full hall would be so much better thanks. But – a disclaimer – if I wanted to do that event, because it sounded fun or would allow me to call in on an old friend I haven’t seen for ages, kill two birds with one stone – I am totally at liberty to do it if I wanted to, if it were my free choice. And you have to keep that in your mind: FREE choice, not one that you’ve been manipulated into taking. Beware the manipulations. The amount of times I’ve been asked to be the after-dinner speaker somewhere, often at a ‘charity event’ but as soon as I’ve mentioned a fee and petrol, I never hear from them again. I imagine them pulling their handbags up in disgust that I’ve actually asked for money. Who do I think I am? Note to self, never say YES to anything on the spot, especially when hammered at a social event. You don’t have your diary on you, you can’t possibly say when you are free. You’ll come back to them. Don’t be bullied or pressured or cornered, you do not have to say YES. You do not have to explain why it’s a NO. And if you do say NO, don’t start imagining then that they have stuck a picture of you on a dartboard because you are a nasty, unhelpful, selfish arse.
Sometimes organisers at events might say that they can’t pay a fee because they want to raise as much money as possible for their charity and every penny counts. If it was a charity close to my heart, then I could choose to do it of course. But I have my own charities and they get the free time I have. We can’t all support every charity, we can’t do everything for free. We need to pay bills and eat. Blimey, some celebs charge £10k just for turning up but we’re feeling guilty about a daily rate of a couple of hundred quid (see Society of Author’s guidance - https://societyofauthors.org/Advice/Rates-Fees). Ticket prices should factor in that cost.
Set out your fee (and your terms - including the 'blue Smarties') from the off because if they're paying you a fee, you're 'worth more' than those who don't take one. This advice is from someone who used to organise lit fests etc. So even if you were going to do it for free, don't. Take the fee and then you donate it if you wish, your choice, but you'll be treated better if you charge. You'll get the respect and the gratitude. Crazy isn't it. Handle it like your PA would handle it.
This is how weird it gets with us. Imagine an event and the organisers decide upon a well known author who they are sure will spin lots of ticket sales. Their lure. Someone of value. They hope to raise a fortune for charity so they want as many people as possible to attend. But they ask the author to do it for free so that it doesn’t eat into their monies raised for said charity. YET… the printers of the tickets are a business and will make a profit. The bookseller attending will make a profit. The caterers will be paid. The venue will be rented. Hmm. Sometimes they won’t even offer petrol either (so I’m also expected to fork out travel costs to turn up at an event I’m not even getting paid for). ‘BUT we can supply you with tea and coffee all day *smiley face*’ they say. Alas, tea won’t pay my mortgage. Try asking your plumber to mend your radiator in exchange for a cuppa and a Mr Kipling’s French Fancy. I nearly always have to ask what the fee will be when approached to do an event because it isn’t mentioned, as if the hope is I’ll forget if it's glossed over. Sometimes the answer is ‘a token fee of X, although most people waive it’. Ooh, a hint there that I’m possibly being unreasonable for asking - you greedy cow. It’s a breath of fresh air when you’re approached to appear and the fee is transparent from the off. And it’s both respectful and respected.
My time is money. I have to take time away from my book which is what pays my wage. I have to work at writing a speech and you can’t write those in an hour, some take days. I have to practice, I have to travel to the event. My time is money, did I say? (I have a friend who isn’t even on Twitter because he won’t write ANYTHING he isn’t paid for. And he’s proud of it. And flipping richer than me by a country mile.)
I felt a bit manipulated recently when I was asked to do something which would have taken a lot of driving time and appearance time for bugger all recompense apart from enough tea to drown me and so I asked Joanne Harris for some advice because I knew I could rely on her as a wise stick. ‘If you want to support the charity, fine, but expecting you do to it for free without giving you the choice seems exploitative and wrong’ she said. And that her experience of working for free is that all it really gets you is more offers to work… for free. She voiced what I knew already but I wanted someone to tell me that I wasn’t being a grasping bitch. I’m not and we shouldn’t be made to feel that way. Our time is ours to give away as we wish. As is our goodwill. Is there any other profession where people are made to feel like this? I'm already thinking 'dare I publish this'?
Lit festivals never pay a lot, we know this and accept it. But you shouldn’t be out of pocket for attending. Not unless you want to be. There was a new lit fest being launched a couple of years ago by fellow author friends who quite candidly asked if there was any chance I could help kick it off. They couldn't pay and they'd understand if I didn't want. I went, I turned down the nominal £20 towards petrol and I had a whale of a time. It was my choice, no one tried to bully or trick me. It was a wonderful success which means the next time they do it, sponsors will most likely be on board and they'll be able to pay a going rate.
And here's another bugbear while I'm purging. The amount of times I've trekked to the other side of the country to sign books for a bookseller and they haven't even asked me if I want a cup of coffee or said 'thanks'. I don't go back to those places now. Isn't that a basic courtesy? We even give our window cleaner a can of pop when he's doing my upstairs (not a euphemism). Value value value. Who values us if we don't value ourselves? Once a four hour round trip to a place that couldn't be bothered advertising I was coming so in the two hour stint, six people turned up in total. Not a cuppa was offered. Not a thank you when I left. I thought 'they'll email me'. They didn't. They asked me back the next year. I, dressing it up in politeness, said that last year was a bit disappointing and why that was. I hoped for a 'Oh goodness, I'm so sorry. Let us put that right.' I got only silence and a big ball of tumbleweed blowing past my desk.
At a very early in my career event with a small readers’ group in Barnsley, a lady slid a tenner across the table to me and said ‘You’re a professional, you have to start charging’. She was right. Do an event for the WI and they pay you, let you sell your books and fill you up with butterfly buns. Fed, watered, good PR job, financially recompensed. Might not be a fortune - £50-£90 as a rough guide, but they're great. And they pass your details around to other WIs. Proper respect, proper value. By doing things for free, I’m not helping any solidarity with my fellow authors. It shouldn't be a shock to anyone to presume we should be paid for a job. It’s not greed, I’m a businesswoman not someone farting around on a typewriter for a laugh. Neither am I Elon Musk who is loaded enough to give up his time for nothing because he doesn’t have a mortgage and he doesn't care that his heating bills have tripled. Except he wouldn’t give his services gratis, he’d charge and want more than a cuppa as an appearance fee, because that’s how business works. No one would say, 'I can't believe Mr Musk has asked for plane fare and a hotel to come and talk to us about space!' It would be entirely expected. So why isn't it with us authors? If we are valued enough to be asked to do something, we should be valued enough to be given proper recompense for it. Raise the money question at the beginning like a business person would. It's a JOB. If you enquire about serving your boiler and the gasman then says 'It's £140' you don't slam the phone down and say 'Well, I can't believe he's mentioned a cost. How dare he, the greedy twat.'
Say NO whenever you want to. It’s not illegal. You are running things, they aren’t running you. Unless you let them and if you are - stop now.
Good luck.
Wise words. I think a lot of giving work away for free starts with new writers (like me) desperate for publicity and we are delighted to be published in lit mags etc. But it's not sustainable and certainly not for those who are aiming to write for a living. Years back I co-organised a small lit festival, and as we had no money we approached local authors and said up front we were unable to pay a fee. A couple declined but several agreed (and have gone on to wonderfully great things.) The following year we were able pay speakers for travel and the next we were able to pay our authors - because we valued them. But I fear there are still many organisations that believe the 'publicity' is enough. It's not.
ReplyDeleteBrilliant post and I subject I'm constantly faced with. And you're correct about the WI circuit-a smashing bunch. I always get asked to give up time to help a friend of a friend who desperately wants to leave the rat race but won't do what I did...spend hours searching and researching when it's easier to take a morning of my time for free. That said, I do enjoy helping when it's well received and people actually listen and do rather than completely ignore. Oh, they then usually go and spend two hundred quid on some scammers get rich writing course but we're happy to not even buy me a coffee. See what you've started now š
ReplyDeleteWhat an excellent blog Milly ,I hope you wear those big girl pants with pride and learn to say NO to those who take you for granted and start to ask for renumerations for events and the said petrol money for getting there . A glass of fizz too might be welcomed as opposed to a cup of Yorkshire tea .I know just how generous you are as I have been lucky enough to be on the receiving end .Nobody cares more than you do for your charities but you have to keep the ones that are closest to your heart ,like the Yorkshire Cat Rescue which is a great cause
ReplyDeleteAnyway just to say your blog made me giggle as well as bringing it home to me just how much award winning authors like yourself are put upon .Good luck to you finding the voice to JUST SAY NO. xx
Very good point Milly. I fear, too, that the extremely low amounts of cash available to authors have given rise to a dog-eat-dog culture where authors are pitted against each other, there is a lot of tomfoolery when it comes to arts council grants etc and we are reduced to tearing each other down and fighting over scraps. I called time on that a while back, for the sake of my health. I think saying no is extremely wise and keeping boundaries strong and healthy. All the best to you, Susan
ReplyDeleteYou are preventing burnout - well done šš¼
ReplyDeleteSadly I don't earn my money from writing but your point about saying no and not feeling guilty is still valid. So hard to do though.
ReplyDeleteIt is not going to be a popular opinion but with the school visits and signing sessions, I think the problem is with the less than clear demarcation between promotion and actual workshop. When I want to advertise, I have to pay too for advertising space. The more on-target the media, the more costly it will be. I am not saying that writers should not be paid, but the positioning of school visits and signing sessions needs to be adjusted. If you are teaching a workshop, it should be about teaching instead of just reading from the book and answering questions. Then it can be clearly differentiated from a promotion event.
ReplyDeleteI personally am okay with paying for school visits, etc, but not all will be because of the blurred positioning. In the case of showbiz celebrities, they do not get paid for interviews or even performances that tie in with their song or movie releases either. They will be paid for their travel and accommodation cost, but not for the appearance. Appearances are only paid when they are commercial shows.
Herein lies another problem. Are schools more a promotion platform for writers? Or are schools venues which can rip material gains from writers' visits?
I hope I have not offended anyone with this reply but I think the issue has roots elsewhere, rather than about who is right or wrong, who is being cheeky and who is not, etc.
Like I said, I am happy to pay but I can also see why there can be disputes regarding this. So, maybe it is time authors start thinking about how they position their visits in terms of both content and purpose.
Clarity is important from both sides. Many novelists rely on monies from appearances and festivals because what they earn from writing does not give them a living wage. Why would someone be shocked that a novelist/artist might want to charge for their services when they would expect a plumber or an electrician to? That's my point.
DeleteLove you Milly. Needs to be said. I am also DREADFUL at saying no and now have stopped reading friend's of friends things for free. Here's to NO (and seeing real friends instead!!) XCesca x
ReplyDelete